College Media Network - Search the largest news resource for college students by college students

A degree isn't worth much without ambition

By Liz Carlston

Staff Writer

Print this article

Published: Thursday, July 2, 2009

Updated: Thursday, July 2, 2009

Liz Carlston

Liz Carlston

Most people who go to college do so not because they enjoy sitting in stuffy lecture halls while listening to monotone-voiced professors, but so they can carve out a better place for themselves in the world when they graduate. Or at least, that is what most expect.

Still, there are plenty of indifferent college students floating through the motions. This same indifference will continue after graduation as they wonder why no employer calls after submitting résumés to the Monster.com or CareerBuilder black holes.

A new study from the Center for Labor Market Studies at Northeastern University in Boston found that college graduates who take jobs below their education level not only earn less, but also trail the earnings of other graduates who were able to secure career-track employment upon graduation.

Students who settle are the ones simply going through the motions of taking classes without a clear focus of where they want to end up after graduation. Some even go to school blindly with no major and hope that eventually they’ll fall into a cushy job just because they went to college. What a stupidly expensive and risky proposition on your future—the world doesn’t work that way.

Take just a few unscientific examples of individuals I have encountered. One student just finished her associates degree at the local community college. She says she wants to be a nurse, but none of her classes fulfilled the nursing pre-requisites. Now she’s discouraged that she wasted two years pursuing a degree that isn’t quite what she needs.

A communication student is currently looking for an internship. He said the bad economy is preventing him from getting any work, but the truth is, he hasn’t been networking or really taking ownership to secure an internship. He has the secret hope that someone will just call and offer a job.

My point in all of this is that you have to plan ahead and take responsibility. You can’t leave your future up to fate or naive wishing that things will simply turn out because you showed up. Find a mentor, a career counselor, a professional who can help coach and guide you through the logistics and obstacles of ending up where you want to be.

In the end, there is no one to blame for your failures and disappointments except yourself. Too many people are trapped in a state of indifference and lack the ambition to develop the necessary problem solving skills to compete in the world.

Comments

11 comments
DesignerGenes
Thu Aug 20 2009 10:19
"Your name" sure sounds like a lawyer. I'm married to one, and this is NOT what lawyers say, even if it's what they mean. Of course, wanting to remain anonymous whenever possible is lawyerly. In fact, not wanting to be found responsible for anything at all is typical of the lawyers who go on to be our politicians - those people famous for opening their big mouths and running off with sound and fury while saying nothing. Clearly this man (or woman) has few friends because they are all beneath him. Keep in mind who this man hates: his hate is for you, and me, and just about everyone and everything on the planet.
Your name
Fri Aug 7 2009 14:37
The author is absolutely correct. Those of you that responded with such passionate objection have exposed yourselves as the same sort of slackers plagued by inertia that the author warns against. I'm a lawyer. I work with another lawyer who went to law school because he didn't have desire to do anything, and some friends suggested lawyers make good money and the education takes less time than medical school. He is easily the worst lawyer I have ever worked with - strictlty 9-5 guy and intent on exerting as little intellectual energy as he can because he feels that doing the bare minimum is "good enough" to get by. He has no desire to improve his skills or knowlege base, then complains about being the lowest paid lawyer at the firm (which he is, despite practicing the same number of years as me). He makes it clear theogh words and conduct that he doesn't have any ambition and it is pathetic to hear him whine that girls aren't interested in him, despite having a "status" career. So no - it is not true that getting a degree is the functional equvalent of ambition. Lack of ambition, especially with a degree is actually a ephimism for one word: "LOSER".

Wake up,people. Doing enough just to get by will rob you of more than just a better paycheck. You will be the person people find too depressing to be around. Ambition is the mark of someone who wants to get more out of life - who wants to be around some lazy f*ck that doesn't give a sh*t? Not me.

DesignerGenes
Tue Jul 14 2009 15:50
Seeking a degree is ambition by definition. For many who don't know what they'll be most interested in studying, going to college - perhaps as the first ever of their family to do so - is a great experiment. This is not a bad thing!
General curiosity, without the need to particularize the hell out of it, should be encouraged.

It seems the principal thrust of this article is to do just that - penalize and marginalize those who didn't "know from the day they started first grade what they wanted to become." What's important is knowing that you want to become.

Get over it!

Bethany J.
Thu Jul 9 2009 14:24
I think if you were to poll college students, you would find that a good portion fit into the "undecided" category for a majority of the time--until they are forced to make a decision. They make the best choice at the time and then when they graduate, they may find they missed the mark and that their happiness might be in another career. It's a gamble. WE ARE ALL HERE TRYING TO DO THE BEST WE CAN at the moment and are here to learn by our choices, albeit some mistakes. One of the neatest guys I know graduated in finance. He got out in the world and decided that wasn't for him and that he wanted to become a doctor. He went back to school for ALL THOSE YEARS required to become a doctor, and no, he didn't have any prerequesites. He became very successful. So what if it took him more time. He is one of the smartest and wisest people I know. Your unscientific examples, I hope aren't actual people who you know and who trust you. I am sure you just made those examples up. You certainly wouldn't want to flaunt someone else's "idiocracy" in front of everyone who reads the Chronicle, let alone them. I would say being "trustworthy, genuine, empathetic" is more important than chosing and aggressively pursung a correct major/career. It might be wise to "put yourself in someone else's place" before you spout off. It's life's lessons that make us who we become. I know some pretty nice people who don't make millions.
Rob
Thu Jul 9 2009 10:50
"My point in all of this is that you have to plan ahead and take responsibility. You can’t leave your future up to fate or naive wishing that things will simply turn out because you showed up."

The author is not correct. Nobody "has to" plan ahead, take responsibility, stop leaving their future up to fate, or stop being naive. Most people eventually develop the ability to, because yeah, following those steps is the best recipe for maturing into capable, independent adults. But a big pile of people don't really want all the responsibility that goes along with being all grown up, so they remain in their immature, dependent state. Some folks go their entire lives without ever becoming adults.

There are various ways to make it in this world without growing up. Lindsay could land a husband who will support her and prefers the company of a lesser being. She might have a trust fund, or other method of letting parents or grandparents pay her bills. She could work for low wages her whole life and just struggle to meet basic needs. She could follow Stephanie's path, and just end up in something, making the best of it. As long my taxes aren't paying her bills, I honestly don't care what she decides to do. Let her make her choices and face the consequences. Dealing with difficult consequences is an excellent way to mature.

Common Sense
Thu Jul 9 2009 05:02
Stephanie and Lindsay, you are both oversensitive idiots. That's abrasive, and true.
Your name
Wed Jul 8 2009 14:04
Stephanie and Lindsey - the point of the article was that people at this stage in life don't need to be treated with kid gloves. So what if the article was abrasive? That was the point. Judgmental? Give me a break. All she said was that people should take ownership of their decisions. If you like the fact that you suck at decisions, great! You're in agreement with the article.
Stephanie
Wed Jul 8 2009 13:21
I agree with you, Lindsay. I found this article quite abrasive. Here's to hoping this staff writer never make it as a motivational speaker. It would have been nice for her to share what steps she took to successfully get from A to B and maybe offer some advice along with their whining "complaint," but I suppose that is why this article is in the opinion column, albeit an arrogant one.

I made it through college blindly, without any direction. It was a feat in and of itself that I completed any schooling, let alone that I received a degree. The experiences I had and the things that I learned about myself during the time I was in school lead me to be the person I am today and down the career path I am on right now. In fact, I consider myself to be very successful and absolutely love what I do. I do not think what I did was "stupid or risky" or a waste of money for that matter.

You further your education not only to put you in a position to have a successful career/make something of yourself but to do just that-- further your education/learn.

Ride your high horse, staff writer, but leave those of us who are treading water, unsure and/or a little gun-shy alone. With time, experience, and a little faith, we'll find our way.

Lindsay N.
Mon Jul 6 2009 19:16
Sometimes you just don't know what you want to do or what you want from life. It takes some longer than others to figure it out or get it right. I don't think there's anything wrong with that. I've seen several people go to school for degrees they later chose not to utilize. And that's okay, so long as they end up doing what makes them happy or works for them. Money isn't everything, you know. This article seems quite judgemental. Also, some don't have as much time as others to do the research and networking. Work commitments, family responsibilities and even parenting can take up a good portion of a student's time. What exactly was your career of choice and is that what you're doing now? Also, did you have to work to pay for school or were checks for college tuition just handed to you? Did you "network and take ownership" or did you coerce family and friends to pull a few strings for you so you could get your foot in the door? You make some decent points but also sound quite ignorant. Does anyone else agree?
Erin
Thu Jul 2 2009 15:52
Right on, I totally agree!
Steve
Thu Jul 2 2009 15:13
Above all get some job experience or expect to start at a low/no wage when you graduate.
It's really hard to find a job in your chosen field if you've never done it professionally.






log out